A customer says their package was lost
Last updated: November 21, 2026
A customer walks in upset. The birthday gift you shipped for them two weeks ago never showed up. They paid you, so they look at you. The carrier lost it, but how you handle the next ten minutes decides if they come back.
Here's the counter playbook, with the real deadlines from USPS and FedEx.
First, check tracking together ๐
Pull up the tracking number while they're standing there. Most "lost" packages fall into one of these:
| Tracking shows | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Delivered | Left at a door, mailroom, neighbor or wrong unit | Ask them to check with neighbors and building staff. Then file |
| Moving, but late | Delayed, not lost | Give it a few more days. Note the date |
| No scans for days | Stuck or actually lost | Wait out the carrier's window, then file |
| Never scanned in | The carrier may not show it as accepted | Find your drop-off or pickup record |
Showing them the screen does a lot. It tells them you're on their side and you have records.
Know the USPS windows ๐
USPS won't take a lost package claim the day after it's late. You have to wait, and you can't wait too long. These come from the USPS claims page, counted from the mailing date on the receipt:
| Service | File after | File before |
|---|---|---|
| Priority Mail Express | 7 days | 60 days |
| Priority Mail | 15 days | 60 days |
| USPS Ground Advantage | 15 days | 60 days |
| Insured Mail | 15 days | 60 days |
| Registered Mail | 15 days | 60 days |
Damaged or missing contents is different: you can file right away, but no later than 60 days after mailing.
Coverage matters too. USPS says Priority Mail, Ground Advantage and Priority Mail Express include up to $100 of insurance in the postage, for merchandise. Customers can buy more, up to $5,000. USPS can't pay anything on uninsured mail, so for anything outside those services with no insurance, the best you can offer is a Missing Mail search.
Know the FedEx windows ๐ฆ
FedEx is more generous on time. For U.S. packages, FedEx says claims for undelivered or lost shipments must be filed within nine months of the shipment date. Damaged or missing contents has to be filed within 60 calendar days.
Either side can start it. FedEx tells recipients to contact the shipper, ask the shipper to file, or file on their own. Shippers file from a logged-in FedEx account.
For UPS, check the claims page on ups.com or your UPS agreement for the current windows. Write them on the same cheat sheet as the others.
Gather the proof ๐งพ
Claims get paid on paperwork. Collect it while the customer is in front of you:
- The tracking or label number. USPS says these run 13 to 34 characters.
- Proof of insurance. The original receipt, or the printed online label record from the software that made the label. For online labels, USPS wants the record to show the tracking number, postage, insurance fee, declared value, mailing date and both ZIP Codes.
- Proof of value. A sales receipt, paid invoice, credit card statement or an online order printout. USPS never pays more than the item's actual value.
- Photos, for damage claims. Have the recipient keep the box, the packing and every item until it's settled. USPS can ask to inspect it, and a missing box can sink the claim.
If you only have the outer packaging and no receipt, USPS can limit payment to $100 on insured mail.
Decide who files ๐ค
USPS lets either the sender or the recipient file, as long as they have the receipt or label record. If both file, USPS pays the one who filed first and got approved. So settle it at the counter:
- You file when you bought the label in your own software and have the record. Tell the customer you'll call when you hear back.
- The customer files when they'd rather handle it. Print the receipt and label record and hand them over.
USPS says it usually decides in 5 to 10 days, and approved claims pay in 7 to 10 business days. If it's denied, there's an appeal within 30 days, then a final appeal within 30 days of that.
Stop the next one at the counter โ
Most of the pain is avoidable with a few habits:
- Offer extra coverage on anything worth more than $100. Say the number out loud.
- Read the address back before you print, apartment number included. Our guide to carrier label adjustments covers why that matters for your fees too.
- Keep every receipt and label record you can pull up in seconds.
- Get a phone number on every shipment so you can follow up.
In a busy season, like the holiday rush, late is more common than lost. Tell customers that before they leave.
Bullship keeps the records handy ๐ป
Bullship lets you buy and compare discounted USPS labels, up to 88% off USPS retail prices, and add your own UPS, FedEx and DHL accounts. When a customer comes back worried, the label is in the system, not in a shoebox. See package tracking and shipping labels.
Good questions ๐ฌ
Can I file a USPS claim on a package with no insurance?
USPS only pays on insured mail. Priority Mail, Ground Advantage and Priority Mail Express include up to $100 of coverage in the postage. For other uninsured mail, USPS points you to a Missing Mail search instead.
Who gets the money, the store or the customer?
USPS pays whoever files first and gets approved, and it never pays more than the item's actual value. Agree with the customer up front who will file, so you don't both do it.
Does the claim refund the postage too?
For a lost USPS package, yes. USPS says postage is included with the claim payment. The insurance fee itself is not refunded.
What if USPS denies the claim?
You can appeal within 30 days of the decision, the same way you filed. If that's denied, there's one final appeal, also within 30 days.
Keep reading
Sources
Ready to make the switch?
Try Bullship free for 14 days. No contract. Free onboarding.
Try 14 days free ๐