Mail keeps coming for a former mailbox customer
Last updated: November 12, 2026
A renter closed their box last month. Their mail didn't get the memo. Here's what USPS rules say you have to do, and a simple process so your staff never has to guess.
What the USPS rules require 📬
These come from the CMRA rules in the USPS Domestic Mail Manual (DMM 508.1.8.4).
| Time since the box closed | What to do with their mail |
|---|---|
| 0 to 6 months | Remail it to the former customer. Remailed mail requires new postage |
| After 6 months | You may return First-Class Mail, USPS Ground Advantage Retail, Priority Mail, Priority Mail Express and accountable mail the next business day, without new postage, endorsed "Undeliverable, Commercial Mail Receiving Agency, No Authorization to Receive Mail for this Addressee" |
On top of that, keep the endorsed PS Form 1583 for at least 6 months after the termination date.
A closing checklist for your counter 📦
When a renter closes their box:
- Record the termination date.
- Get a forwarding address in writing.
- Agree how remailing postage gets paid. A deposit or a card on file both work.
- Collect keys.
- Set a reminder for 6 months from the termination date.
- Add the termination date in the USPS CMRA system. It has to be in before your next quarterly certification.
Day to day, after the box closes 🧠
- Keep a "closed boxes" bin separate from active boxes, so no one puts a former renter's mail into a box you've re-rented.
- Remail on a schedule. Once or twice a week is easier than every day.
- Log what you remail. Date, number of pieces and postage. If the former renter asks, you have the answer.
- Re-renting the box? Fine. Their mail still gets remailed for 6 months, so check names before you sort.
Packages for the former renter 📫
Treat them the same way: don't put them in the new renter's box. Contact the former renter about forwarding, and follow your written closing agreement on how long you'll hold packages.
Make closing a box a 2-minute job 💻
The rules are easy. Remembering them six months later is the hard part. Bullship keeps each mailbox customer's history, box number and status in one place, so your team can see at a glance who's active and who's closed. See mailbox rental features or the full CMRA guide.
Good questions 📬
Who pays the postage to remail it?
USPS says remailed mail requires new postage. Agree how the renter covers it (a forwarding deposit, or a card on file) before they close the box.
What if the renter left no forwarding address?
Ask for one at closing, every time. Put it on your closing checklist so it never gets skipped.
Can I throw the mail away?
No. Follow the remail and return rules. Mail isn't yours to discard.
Keep reading
Sources
Ready to make the switch?
Try Bullship free for 14 days. No contract. Free onboarding.
Try 14 days free 🎉